Male or female?

What to look for in species that are not obviously sexually dimorphic?

1 Like

That is a great question and I think it is highly dependent on the species. Maybe people with more on-the-field experience like @Peter_Hall or @kmcfarland might have some tips. For what I could find, there are a few subtle signs that might need a field microscope to spot, but they could still help:

  1. Body Size:
  • Females are often slightly larger, especially in the abdomen, due to egg-carrying. However, size differences can be subtle and require comparison among multiple individuals.
  1. Abdomen Morphology:
  • Males: Typically have a slimmer, more tapered abdomen with claspers (valvae) at the tip for mating.
  • Females: Usually possess a broader, rounded abdomen with an ovipositor (egg-laying structure) at the tip.
  • Examine the abdomen’s terminal segments under magnification for these features.
  1. Androconia (Scent Scales):
  • Males often have specialized scales or hair-like structures (e.g., on wings or thorax) that release pheromones. Look for folded forewing patches, “sex brands,” or tufts of scales, which are male-specific in many species.
  1. Behavioral Cues:
  • Males may exhibit territorial behavior, patrolling flight patterns, or aggressive interactions.
  • Females are often observed probing vegetation for host plants to lay eggs.
  • During mating, the upper individual is typically male.
  1. Genitalia Examination:
  • For definitive identification, microscopic examination of genitalia is required. Males have complex clasping structures, while females have a genital opening and ovipositor. This is common in scientific studies but less practical in the field.
  1. Wing Structure:
  • Subtle differences in wing venation, shape, or UV-reflective patterns (invisible to humans) may exist. These often require specialized tools or imaging techniques.
  1. Antennae:
  • While less common in butterflies, some species may show slight differences in antennae structure (e.g., thickness or sensory capabilities), though this is more typical in moths.

Practical Tips for Field Observation:

  • Focus on abdomen shape and presence of androconia as primary indicators.
  • Use a hand lens to inspect the abdomen tip or wing scales.
  • Note behavioral patterns over time to infer sex.

For rigorous scientific work, dissection or DNA analysis may be necessary.

1 Like